A contest run by superangelo128 in August 2012.
ONe of the required rules of the contest was that in order to "properly" vote you needed to have read both VNs in the match. This was dealt with having 5 poll options: Two for options where you have read both, two for where you have only read one, and one where you have read/do not like either one.
In the Final Sengoku Rance got a very close win over Ever17.
lol X-stats Sengoku Rance- 50.00%
Phoenix Wright series- 49.35% Ever17- 49.33% Muv-Luv series- 48.52% 999- 43.18% Tsukihime- 42.62% Kono Yo no Hate de Koi wo Utau Shoujo YU-NO- 42.62% Sharin no Kuni- 40.93%
Dues Machina Demonbane- 38.01% Symphonic Rain- 37.14% Fate/Stay Night- 37.66% Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai!- 36.86% Saya no Uta- 35.87% Kamidori Alchemy Mesiter- 34.01% Cross+Channel- 33.58% Higurashi no Naku Koro ni- 32.88% G-senjou no Maou- 31.60%
Umineko no Naku Koro ni- 29.71% Clannad- 26.58% Steins;Gate- 26.32% Little Busters- 25.47% True Remembrance- 24.66% Edelweiss- 24.26% Kikougai the Cyber Slayer- 23.82% Katawa Shoujo- 22.99% Remember11- 21.06% Kira Kira- 20.50%
Swan Song- 19.80% Yume Miru Kusuri- 19.08% Planetarian- 13.33% Utawarerumono- 12.84% Kanon- 12.29%